Disparate impact class action certified, despite U.S. Supreme Court ruling in Wal-Mart

July 15, 2011 by

The Honorable Nicholas Garaufis, a district court judge from the Eastern District of New York entered an order in the NYC Firefighters case, applying and, to a degree, limiting, the Supreme Court’s decision in Wal-Mart.  He certified subclasses under Rule 23(b)(3), including claims for compensatory damages.

Judge Garaufis said that issue certification of bifurcated liability phase questions under Rule 23(c)(4) for a disparate impact case is fully consistent with Wal-Mart.  He also held that the court would determine aggregate backpay, retroactive seniority, and priority hiring relief on a class wide basis.  The judge held that there would be an individual claims process that would provide the City with the opportunity to raise its individual defenses.  However, the court ruled that the subclasses could waive the right to jury trial in the remedial phase, so long as class members were provided notice, so they could opt out. He said a special master could handle the 7100 individual claims.

The case made it clear that Wal-Mart should be limited to disparate impact and pattern and practice cases.

Click here for a copy of the decision.

Steve Larson
An experienced trial lawyer who handles both hourly and contingent fee cases, Steve has expertise in class actions, consumer cases, antitrust litigation, securities litigation, corporate disputes, intellectual property disputes, unfair competition claims, employment matters, and disputes involving family wealth. Steve regularly represents individuals and businesses in federal and state court and has obtained class-wide recovery in multiple class actions. A veteran practitioner, Steve's clients value his creative approach to resolving complex litigation matters.

Legal Disclaimer

The information contained in this blog does not constitute legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. We make no claims, promises or guarantees about the accuracy, completeness, or adequacy of the information contained in or linked to this blog.